NoteCollateral
Bitcoin as institutional collateral: haircuts, custody and margin
How prime brokers and lenders now treat BTC against Treasuries and equities, and where the gap is closing.
Collateral is where a settlement thesis meets a credit desk. An asset can be held, admired and even settled in, but it becomes part of the financial system when a lender will advance money against it. This note sets out how the firm reads the treatment of Bitcoin as collateral by prime brokers and lenders, and where it sees the gap with Treasuries and equities closing.
What a haircut is for
A haircut is the lender’s answer to three questions: how far the collateral’s price might move before the position can be closed, how quickly it can be sold, and how certain the lender is that it actually controls the asset. The first is volatility, the second liquidity, the third custody and legal title. Treasuries score well on all three; equities are discounted for the first; and Bitcoin has historically been discounted for all three at once.
The firm’s reading is that the three are moving at different speeds. Price volatility remains the dominant input and will set the floor for haircuts for some time. Liquidity, measured by the depth available to a lender who must sell in a hurry, has deepened on the venues an institution is permitted to use. Custody and title, the questions that once made the asset ineligible rather than merely expensive, are the ones closing fastest.
Custody, and who holds what
A lender taking Bitcoin as collateral needs to know that the asset is segregated, that it cannot be rehypothecated without consent, and that it can be taken on default without a court order in a foreign jurisdiction. Qualified custodians, tri-party arrangements and multi-signature controls have each been adapted for this. The structure that is emerging looks familiar from the securities world: the borrower retains economic ownership, the custodian holds the keys, and the lender holds a perfected security interest that the custodian will honour on instruction.
What is new is that the asset itself can enforce some of those terms. A multi-signature arrangement in which the custodian, the lender and the borrower each hold a key can make a transfer impossible without the agreed quorum. That does not replace the legal agreement, but it reduces the lender’s reliance on the custodian’s operational good faith, and it is one reason the firm expects haircuts to narrow as these arrangements become standard.
Margin and the daily cycle
The second place Bitcoin differs from Treasuries is that it trades continuously. A margin call issued on a Friday evening against an equity position waits until Monday; a call against Bitcoin can be met, or the collateral sold, at any hour. For the lender this is a benefit that cuts both ways: exposure can be closed sooner, but the processes for issuing calls and accepting top-ups have to run when the lender’s staff do not. The desks that have built for this treat the asset more favourably than those that have not, and the difference shows up in the terms they offer.
Where the gap is closing
Three things would narrow the remaining gap with Treasuries, in the firm’s view. First, a settled body of law on perfection of security interests in digital assets across the jurisdictions where institutional lending takes place. Second, a custody market in which the borrower can choose among several qualified custodians a lender will recognise, so that the custodian is not also the gatekeeper. Third, the lender’s own experience: haircuts fall when a desk has lived through a drawdown with the collateral and found that it could be sold and the position closed as modelled.
None of these is a technical problem. All three are in progress. The firm’s expectation is that Bitcoin will be treated as a standard, if volatile, form of institutional collateral well before it is treated as a settlement asset by the same institutions, and that the collateral use will be the path by which the settlement use arrives.
A note on what this piece does not say. It makes no claim about the direction of the asset’s price and sets out no figures for haircuts, which vary by lender, jurisdiction and borrower and change often. Readers who want current terms should ask a lender.