LetterSettlement

Neutral money, neutral ledger

Why a settlement layer with no issuer and no operator is the one institutions can agree to share.

By Dylan CarterSeptember 29, 202612 min read

Institutions that compete cannot share infrastructure one of them controls. That single constraint explains much of the shape of the financial system: why clearing houses are owned by their members, why central banks sit above commercial ones, why messaging standards are governed by committee. It also explains, in the firm’s view, why the settlement layer for on-chain assets will be the one with no issuer and no operator.

The problem of the shared ledger

A shared ledger is only useful if every participant believes the record is the same for everyone and that no participant can change it alone. In a closed system that belief is produced by governance: a rulebook, a membership and a body that can be sued. On a public chain it must be produced by the chain itself, because the participants may be in different jurisdictions, under different regulators, and in direct competition.

Most public chains produce that belief through a mix of code and institutions: a foundation that stewards the protocol, a company that writes most of the software, a set of validators small enough to coordinate. Each of those is a point at which a participant can be favoured or a transaction reversed, and each is therefore a reason for a competitor not to settle there. The chain may be excellent for applications. It is compromised as a base layer, because a base layer must be acceptable to parties who distrust each other and distrust its stewards.

What neutrality requires

The firm’s test for a neutral ledger has four parts. No one can change the money’s supply rules. No one can reverse or censor a settled transaction. No one is needed for the system to keep running. And the history of the system shows these properties holding under pressure, not merely asserted in a document.

Bitcoin passes the test in a way the firm has not found elsewhere. Its supply rules have been contested and have not changed. Attempts to alter the protocol against the will of its users have failed in public. Its operation depends on no company, foundation or named individual. And it has run through market collapses, exchange failures, state hostility and internal schism without a settled transaction being undone.

Why institutions can agree to share it

Neutrality matters because it is the property that lets adversaries cooperate. Two banks that would never settle on each other’s books can both settle on a ledger neither controls. Two sovereigns that would never hold each other’s liabilities can both hold an asset neither issues. The value of a neutral settlement layer rises with the number and the mutual suspicion of the parties using it, which is the opposite of how most networks behave.

This is the same logic that made gold the settlement asset between states for centuries: not because it was convenient, but because no state issued it. Bitcoin carries that property into a form that can settle across a network in the time it takes to confirm a block, and it adds something gold never had, which is a record of ownership that every participant can read and none can alter.

The objection, and the firm’s answer

The usual objection is that a ledger without a steward cannot adapt. Rules that cannot be changed cannot be fixed. The firm takes the objection seriously and answers it in two parts. First, a base layer should change rarely, because every change is a moment at which neutrality can be lost; the slowness is the point. Second, the adaptation happens above the base layer, in the custody, issuance and settlement networks built on it, where change is fast and competition is welcome. The division of labour is familiar: the rules of the game are fixed, and the players innovate.

What follows

If the firm is right, the settlement layer for on-chain finance is not chosen by committee or by the best feature set. It is chosen by elimination, as each alternative is found to have someone who can be asked to intervene. Bitcoin is what remains. The firm’s research and capital are concentrated on it for that reason, and on the businesses building the layers above it where the work of adaptation is done.

The letter

Research by email, when it is published.

Letters, notes and event invitations. No marketing.